COMMENTS ON THE ART MARKET
Volume 14
Normally I begin my newsletters with a ‘story’ of interest, however this month I am starting off with my series --- what you need to think about when purchasing a work of art. After, this month’s ‘story’ will beautifully illustrate why people need to concern themselves with whom they do business and about a work’s:
Title
Title is an interesting legal term used to describe, in our case, the ownership of a work of art. Questions often asked are: Do you have ‘title’ to the work? Are you the owner of the work? Does the work have ‘clear title’?
Determining if the person you are purchasing a work from has clear title, or the legal right to sell the work, is extremely difficult. Unlike other items one may purchase – cars, stocks or real estate – works of art (and for that matter jewelry, furniture, porcelain, and most collectibles) are not items that are registered in some database where one can see who the real owner is. Most works of art have changed hands many times and the actual chain of ownership (a work’s provenance – which I will discuss next month) is often very vague. In many cases it is nearly impossible to verify who the actual owner is.
We have all read stories, in recent years, about all the Nazi looted art, or about soldiers who ‘took’ works that they found during the Second World War, and how many of these works ended up in major public and private collections. When a stolen work is discovered and proof is shown that the work never had clear title, the current owner is usually forced to return the work, to either the true owner or their heirs, and is out the money they spent.
So, what is a buyer to do? Well, your best option is to deal with reputable and well established firms who will stand behind the works they sell. In other words, should an issue ever arise concerning the title of a work purchased, that establishment will take the piece back and refund your purchase price.
Keep in mind that this risk is even more present in the online auction world. Most people trading on the Internet know nothing about each other. Besides the obvious risk that you may pay for something and never receive it, how do you know that the work that being offered is actually owned by the seller, or that the seller has the legal right to offer it? And what if the work turns out to be stolen? Will you ever be able to find the person who sold it? Will you ever get your money back? In the faceless Internet world, the answers to these questions are pretty obvious.
If this unfortunate turn of events should happen it is usually the last person holding the work that is “out the money”. Again, to help protect yourself from being the last one, it is advisable to deal with well-established firms (dealers, galleries, auctions, etc.). Those that are leaders in their field, have developed great reputations, and have been, and will most likely be, in business for many years to come.
On a final note, most reputable galleries do their ‘due diligence’. They want to be as sure as possible that the individuals they are buying from are the actual owners, have clear title, and the legal right to sell. There is nothing more embarrassing then having to call a client, years after they bought something, and inform that that a particular work in their collection was stolen and must be returned.
______________________
An Interesting Story About Title
Back in November the Maine Antique Digest reported that an out-of-court settlement was made between Butterfields, the California auction house that is now owned by eBay, and several individuals that ended an episode that could have forced the firm to make changes in the rules under which it does business.
While there is a lot to this story, the short version is as follows. A group of individuals stole a large collection of rare Eskimo/Inuit objects and over a period of 5 years had sold them through Butterfields. The works were originally collected by a Mr. Joseph Chilberg, during the early 20th century, and had been stored in the basement of the family’s home for many years. In 1998 Chilberg’s grandson paid a visit to the home and discovered that many of the items were missing. It turns out that the grandson had rented out the house to a friend whose daughter was involved in the theft --- so much for trusting friends!
In October of 2000 the grandson brought suit against Butterfields and 30 of their clients (the buyers of the stolen material); an out-of-court settlement was made. Then Robert Fellmeth, a San Diego attorney, acting as a representative for himself and a small group of buyers, filed a counterclaim against Butterfields --- they were seeking recovery of all damages resulting from the purchases and the striking of any disclaimer of responsibility of passing title on the part of Butterfields in the future.
Well, as you can guess, this suit was also settled and there was no legal ruling on the matter…however, it is now clearly stated by Butterfields that: Except as expressly provided above, all property is sold ‘as is’ and neither Butterfields Auctioneers Corp., nor the consignor makes any representation or warranty, expressed or implied, as to the title, merchantability, fitness or condition of the property or as to the correctness of description, genuineness, attribution, provenance or period of the property…”
WOW! Not only was that a mouthful, but they sure take the phrase caveat emptor (buyer beware) to a new level! Not only do they not guarantee title, but also, it appears from this statement the only thing they do guarantee is that the item physically exists!! Or do they?
Howard L. Rehs
© Rehs Galleries, Inc., New York –February 2002, December 2008 & November 2015
Gallery Updates: We have made a few interesting changes to our site. This month we added a FAQ’s page (Frequently Asked Questions). While there are only a few questions there now, we will be expanding this feature in the months to come. We have also added a page that discusses the gallery’s Authentication Services. To reach these new features please click on the ‘Contact Us/Newsletters’ button on our site.
The gallery has also acquired new works by Louis Aston Knight, Edouard Cortès, Antoine Blanchard and Sally Swatland – some of which have been added to our site.
Virtual Exhibitions: This month we have added a small exhibition featuring the work of the American still life artist George C. Lambdin (1830-1896) to our web site. The exhibit features a biography, photo of the artist and color images of his work; the direct URL is:
George Cochran Lambdin – The Vintage Rose
We have also expanded the following Virtual Exhibitions: George Armfield, John F. Herring, Jr. & Henry John Yeend King - please take a look.
Among the new ‘sold’ works that have been added to our Virtual Exhibitions are: Henry John Yeend King’s Milking Time; Antoine Blanchard’s Place Vendôme (a very interesting and unusual work by the artist); Edouard Cortes’ Sacre Coeur (this particular work is featured in the Klein book on page 185), Place de la Republique, Les Grands Boulevards, Theatre des Varietes, and a number of works by Sally Swatland, including Sunday at the Shore and Along the Connecticut Shore.
Next Month: I will be discussing a work’s Provenance - what is it and does it really matter?
SUBSCRIBE
To subscribe to our monthly Comments On The Art Market newsletter,
click here.
ARCHIVES
October 1, 2024 - Volume 286
September 1, 2024 - Volume 285
August 1, 2024 - Volume 284
July 1, 2024 - Volume 283
June 1, 2024 - Volume 282
May 1, 2024 - Volume 281
April 1, 2024 - Volume 280
March 1, 2024 - Volume 279
February 1, 2024 - Volume 278
January 1, 2024 - Volume 277
December 1, 2023 - Volume 276
November 1, 2023 - Volume 275
October 1, 2023 - Volume 274
September 1, 2023 - Volume 273
August 1, 2023 - Volume 272
July 1, 2023 - Volume 271
June 1, 2023 - Volume 270
May 1, 2023 - Volume 269
April 1, 2023 - Volume 268
March 1, 2023 - Volume 267
February 1, 2023 - Volume 266
January 1, 2023 - Volume 265
December 1, 2022 - Volume 264
November 1, 2022 - Volume 263
October 1, 2022 - Volume 262
September 1, 2022 - Volume 261
August 1, 2022 - Volume 260
July 1, 2022 - Volume 259
June 1, 2022 - Volume 258
May 1, 2022 - Volume 257
April 1, 2022 - Volume 256
March 1, 2022 - Volume 255
February 1, 2022 - Volume 254
January 1, 2022 - Volume 253
December 1, 2021 - Volume 252
November 1, 2021 - Volume 251
October 1, 2021 - Volume 250
September 1, 2021 - Volume 249
August 1, 2021 - Volume 248
July 1, 2021 - Volume 247
June 1, 2021 - Volume 246
May 1, 2021 - Volume 245
April 1, 2021 - Volume 244
March 1, 2021 - Volume 243
February 1, 2021 - Volume 242
January 1, 2021 - Volume 241
December 1, 2020 - Volume 240
November 1, 2020 - Volume 239
October 1, 2020 - Volume 238
September 1, 2020 - Volume 237
August 1, 2020 - Volume 236
July 1, 2020 - Volume 235
June 1, 2020 - Volume 234
May 1, 2020 - Volume 233
April 1, 2020 - Volume 232
March 1, 2020 - Volume 231
February 1, 2020 - Volume 230
January 1, 2020 - Volume 229
December 1, 2019 - Volume 228
November 1, 2019 - Volume 227
October 1, 2019 - Volume 226
September 1, 2019 - Volume 225
August 1, 2019 - Volume 224
July 1, 2019 - Volume 223
June 1, 2019 - Volume 222
May 1, 2019 - Volume 221
April 1, 2019 - Volume 220
March 1, 2019 - Volume 219
February 1, 2019 - Volume 218
January 1, 2019 - Volume 217
December 1, 2018 - Volume 216
November 1 2018 - Volume 215
October 1, 2018 - Volume 214
September 1, 2018 - Volume 213
August 1, 2018 - Volume 212
July 1, 2018 - Volume 211
June 1, 2018 - Volume 210
May 1, 2018 - Volume 209
April 1, 2018 - Volume 208
March 1, 2018 - Volume 207
February 1, 2018 - Volume 206
January 1, 2018 - Volume 205
December 1, 2017 - Volume 204
November 1, 2017 - Volume 203
October 1, 2017 - Volume 202
September 1, 2017 - Volume 201
August 1, 2017 - Volume 200
July 1, 2017 - Volume 199
June 1, 2017 - Volume 198
May 1, 2017 - Volume 197
April 1, 2017 - Volume 196
March 1, 2017 - Volume 195
February 1, 2017 - Volume 194
January 1, 2017 - Volume 193
December 1, 2016 - Volume 192
November 1, 2016 - Volume 191
October 1, 2016 - Volume 190
September 1, 2016 - Volume 189
August 1, 2016 - Volume 188
July 1, 2016 - Volume 187
June 1, 2016 - Volume 186
May 1, 2016 - Volume 185
April 1, 2016 - Volume 184
March 4, 2016 - Volume 183
February 5, 2016 - Volume 182
January 1, 2016 - Volume 181
December 1, 2015 - Volume 180
November 2, 2015 - Volume 179
October 1, 2015 - Volume 178
September 1, 2015 - Volume 177
August 1, 2015 - Volume 176
July 1, 2015 - Volume 175
June 1, 2015 - Volume 174
May 1, 2015 - Volume 173
April 1, 2015 - Volume 172
March 1, 2015 - Volume 171
February 1, 2015 - Volume 170
January 1, 2015 - Volume 169
December 1, 2014 - Volume 168
November 1, 2014 - Volume 167
October 1, 2014 - Volume 166
September 1, 2014 - Volume 165
August 1, 2014 - Volume 164
July 1, 2014 - Volume 163
June 1, 2014 - Volume 162
May 1, 2014 - Volume 161
April 1, 2014 - Volume 160
March 1, 2014 - Volume 159
February 1, 2014 - Volume 158
January 1, 2014 - Volume 157
December 1, 2013 - Volume 156
November 1, 2013 - Volume 155
October 1, 2013 - Volume 154
September 1, 2013 - Volume 153
August 1, 2013 - Volume 152
July 1, 2013 - Volume 151
June 1, 2013 - Volume 150
May 2, 2013 - Volume 149
April 2013 - Volume 148
March 2013 - Volume 147
Feb 2013 - Volume 146
January 2013 - Volume 145
December 2012 - Volume 144
November 2012 - Volume 143
October 2012 - Volume 142
September 2012 - Volume 141
August 2012 - Volume 140
July 2012 - Volume 139
June 2012 - Volume 138
May 2012 - Volume 137
April 2012 - Volume 136
March 2012 - Volume 135
February 2012 - Volume 134
January 2012 - Volume 133
December 2011 - Volume 132
November 2011 - Volume 131
October 2011 - Volume 130
September 2011 - Volume 129
August 2011 - Volume 128
July 2011 - Volume 127
June 2011 - Volume 126
May 2011 - Volume 125
May 2011 - Volume 125A
April 2011 - Volume 124
March 2011 - Volume 123
February 2011 - Volume 122
January 2011 - Volume 121
December 2010 - Volume 120
November 2010 - Volume 119
October 2010 - Volume 118
September 2010 - Volume 117
August 2010 - Volume 116
July 2010 - Volume 115
June 2010 - Volume 114
May 2010 - Volume 113
April 2010 - Volume 112
March 2010 - Volume 111
February 2010 - Volume 110
January 2010 - Volume 109
December 2009 - Volume 108
November 2009 - Volume 107
October 2009 - Volume 106
September 2009 - Volume 105
August 2009 - Volume 104
July 2009 - Volume 103
June 2009 - Volume 102
May 2009 - Volume 101
April 2009 - Volume 100
March 2009 - Volume 99
February 2009 - Volume 98
January 2009 - Volume 97
December 2008 - Volume 96
November 2008 - Volume 95
October 2008 - Volume 94
September 2008 - Volume 93
August 2008 - Volume 92
July 2008 - Volume 91
June 2008 - Volume 90
May 2008 - Volume 89
April 2008 - Volume 88
March 2008 - Volume 87
February 2008 - Volume 86
January 2008 - Volume 85
December 2007 - Volume 84
November 2007 - Volume 83
October 2007 - Volume 82
September 2007 - Volume 81
August 2007 - Volume 80
July 2007 - Volume 79
June 2007 - Volume 78
May 2007 - Volume 77
April 2007 - Volume 76
March 2007 - Volume 75
February 2007 - Volume 74
January 2007 - Volume 73
December 2006 - Volume 72
November 2006 - Volume 71
October 2006 - Volume 70
September 2006 - Volume 69
August 2006 - Volume 68
July 2006 - Volume 67
June 2006 - Volume 66
May 2006 - Volume 65
April 2006 - Volume 64
March 2006 - Volume 63
February 2006 - Volume 62
January 2006 - Volume 61
December 2005 - Volume 60
November 2005 - Volume 59
October 2005 - Volume 58
September 2005 - Volume 57
August 2005 - Volume 56
July 2005 - Volume 55
June 2005 - Volume 54
May 2005 - Volume 53
April 2005 - Volume 52
March 2005 - Volume 51
February 2005 - Volume 50
January 2005 - Volume 49
December 2004 - Volume 48
November 2004 - Volume 47
October 2004 - Volume 46
September 2004 - Volume 45
August 2004 - Volume 44
July 2004 - Volume 43
June 2004 - Volume 42
May 2004 - Volume 41
April 2004 - Volume 40
March 2004 - Volume 39
February 2004 - Volume 38
January 2004 - Volume 37
December 1, 2003 - Volume 36
November 2003 - Volume 35
October 2003 - Volume 34
September 2003 - Volume 33
August 2003 - Volume 32
July 2003 - Volume 31
June 2003 - Volume 30
May 2003 - Volume 29
April 2003 - Volume 28
March 1, 2003 - Volume 27
February 1, 2003 - Volume 26
January 1, 2003 - Volume 25
December 1, 2002 - Volume 24
November 1, 2002 - Volume 23
October 1, 2002 (Updated: January 16, 2016) - Volume 22
September 1, 2002 (Edited 2015) - Volume 21
August 1, 2002 - Volume 20
July 1, 2002 - Volume 19
June 1, 2002 - Volume 18
May 1, 2002 (Edited 2008) - Volume 17
April 1, 2002 (Edited 2008) - Volume 16
March 1, 2002 (Edited 2008) - Volume 15
February 1, 2002 (Edited 2008) - Volume 14
January 1, 2002 (Edited 2008) - Volume 13
December 1, 2001 - Volume 12
November 1, 2001 (Edited 2008) - Volume 11
October 1, 2001 - Volume 10
September 1, 2001 (Edited 2008) - Volume 9
August 1, 2001 (Edited 2008) - Volume 8
July 1, 2001 (Edited 2008) - Volume 7
June 1, 2001 (Edited 2008) - Volume 6
May 1, 2001 (Edited 2008) - Volume 5
April 1, 2001 (Edited 2008) - Volume 4
March 1, 2001 (Edited 2008) - Volume 3
February 1, 2001 (Edited 2008) - Volume 2
January 1, 2001 (Edited 2008) - Volume 1